Bed goes up, bed goes down, bed goes up, bed goes down.
– Homer Simpson
Since the GFC stocks have been the perfect place to hide. In fact, there has been no safer bet with stock markets around the world trading at multiples of their GFC lows. Here’s how major stock markets around the world performed (total return) since the bottom of the GFC:
(orange line – Australia, purple line – Asia, green line – Europe, blue line – US, red – Emerging Markets)
Only when the tide goes out do you discover who’s been swimming naked.
– Warren Buffett
Financial markets however, have no regard for what you want or what you need, and will turn on you like the Melbourne weather leaving you perplexed as to which season it is.
The recent spasm of news coverage on the stock market correction prompted me to assess the damage done on stocks. For the last two months, these were the headlines investors have been reading – how exciting!
I’m not sure who defined a market correction being a decline of 10% or more, but it’s the widely accepted definition. What good is it for investors to know that the correction has begun based on some meaningless threshold someone fabricated? Why is the threshold not 12%, or 15%? Why should a manufactured definition trigger investors to revisit their investment strategy? To me, this threshold seems illogical, and to base investment decisions on these definitions seems foolish.
Let’s take a look at what all the fuss is about. Here’s a chart showing the total return of the above indices since 8 October (when the decline began) to Friday, 23 November 2018:
Within two months, the US stock market is down 10.69%, Europe is down 9.05%, Asia down 7.97%, Australia down 5.92%, and Emerging Markets down 5.25%. Having said this, if we were to look at peak to trough using 52 week highs, the chart above would look different again. In fact, Emerging Markets would look a lot worse if we pulled the start date back to earlier on in the year. It doesn’t matter where you were invested your money, there really was nowhere to hide.
If you think that’s bad, just spare a moment for the tech investors. Here are the FAANGs (Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, Google) against the S&P500 (orange line) and Nasdaq (grey line):
(purple line – Facebook, green line – Amazon, blue line – Apple, yellow line – Google)
Hey, what do you expect after a run up like this:
Netflix’s market cap is currently sitting at US$112 billion. To put that into perspective, Citigroup is currently valued at US$150 billion. Number of employees at each company: Citigroup – 209,000, Netflix – 5,400. Revenue (2018 est): Citigroup – US$216,000,000, Netflix – US$16 billion. Net income (2018 est): Citigroup – US$18 billion, Netflix US$671 million.
Markets can remain irrational for a lot longer than you and I can remain solvent.
– John Maynard Keynes
Most money managers will highlight and emphasize performance for a select period of time (I’ll let you decide why), so it’s very useful to me (and investors) to look at things through a wider lens. So here it goes – the recent market declines since the GFC for stock markets around the world:
It comes as no surprise that the asset class that has performed the best over the last 10 years is the one that has fallen the most when things are seem a little uncertain.
Even following a market “correction”, the US stock market is still up 265%, the Australian market up 144%, and Asia, Europe, and Emerging Markets up 123%, 80%, and 59% respectively.
There are several narratives that are making headlines justifying the recent market decline. The general theme goes something like this: This bull market has been running hot for almost 10 years. Interest rates are rising, and cost pressures are rising, which will cause inflation. Whatever narrative you decide makes most sense to you, the reality is that the news that is floating around is not new and is probably priced into current market valuations anyway.
At the end of the day, the more you pay for an asset, the less the future expected return. The less you pay for an asset, the greater the future expected return. In life, and in financial markets, things sometimes just don’t make any sense – although they eventually do. Don’t try and keep up with the Jones’ or get caught up in the market and media hype – it takes guts, discipline, patience and time to make money.
When you decide to embark on the journey of investing, remember the wise words of Homer Simpson – bed goes up, bed goes down.
- Charts and headlines – Thomson Reuters
- Returns are denominated in AUD for all charts except the FAANGs